My Formal Academic Journey 2008 - 2026
From Formal Academic Qualifications to the Establishment and Continuation of Our Tribal Whare Wānanga — Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti.
1. Returning Home: The Beginning of an Unexpected Academic Journey
My mainstream academic journey began in 2008, following my return home from Australia as a 501 deportee. I had experienced a fatal attraction relationship that was completely wrong for me. I returned to Aotearoa carrying considerable shame, with my head hanging down, uncertain about my future and not knowing whether I would ever amount to anything. I was at a point in my life where I needed to find direction again. I had to rebuild my confidence and find something meaningful to pursue.
In 2008, I eventually gathered enough courage to enrol in the Bachelor of Mātauranga Māori programme at Te Whare Wānanga Ō Awanuiārangi. At the end of my first year, I was progressing well, but the programme felt too easy. I wrote a letter to the Academic Board asking whether I could undertake my Master's degree at the same time.
My request was declined.
Surprisingly, towards the end of 2008, I received a pānui by email from Te Wānanga Ō Raukawa. It invited applicants with a good command of Te Reo Māori and written Māori to apply for entry into its Master's programme, Te Tāhūhū Mātauranga Māori.
I applied and was accepted.
In 2009, I was enrolled simultaneously in a Bachelor's degree in Mātauranga Māori at Te Whare Wānanga Ō Awanuiārangi and a Master's degree at Te Wānanga Ō Raukawa. My Master's research focused on Te Ahurewatanga Ō Te Tohunga Ahurewa. I thoroughly enjoyed both programmes and graduated from both in 2011.
Looking back, what began as an attempt to rebuild my life following my return from Australia became a significant period of intellectual and academic development. Within three years, I had completed two qualifications in Mātauranga Māori. My academic ambition was already extending beyond the conventional progression of one qualification at a time. I was seeking opportunities to advance my understanding and research more deeply.
2. The PhD: Restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga
In 2012, I submitted an Expression of Interest to enter the PhD programme at Te Whare Wānanga Ō Awanuiārangi. It took an entire year for my Expression of Interest to be accepted because the university struggled to understand how I had completed such a substantial amount of academic work between 2009 and 2011, graduating with both a Bachelor's and Master's degree in Mātauranga Māori in 2011. At the end of 2012, I was finally accepted into the PhD programme.
My research topic was centred on:
Visioning Our Grestest Potential: The Restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga in a Contemporary Context.
This was not simply an historical investigation into the existence of traditional Māori educational institutions. I was interested in the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga and its place within a contemporary Indigenous environment. We had agreed to produce three pieces of work:
1. One written in Te Reo Māori.
2. One written in English.
3. One based on Applied Indigenous Knowledge, requiring a minimum of 15 years' experience as an Indigenous practitioner in the subject being researched.
This agreement was fundamental to the research I was undertaking. My chosen methodology was Applied Indigenous Knowledge shared with me by Distinguished Professor Manulani Meyer from Hawaii. I did not want to spend my time simply referencing mainstream academic scholars who had no direct relationship with the knowledge, practice or subject matter I was researching.
I wanted the research to be examined through the depth of Indigenous knowledge, lived experience, whakapapa and actual practice, internal and intuitive knowledge. My position was that Indigenous knowledge should not have to depend entirely on mainstream academic scholarship to establish its intellectual legitimacy. There was another dimension to this methodology.
I believed that someone researching a particular Indigenous knowledge system should have a meaningful relationship with that knowledge. The minimum 15 years of Indigenous practitioner experience was intended to establish that relationship through lived practice rather than relying exclusively on secondary academic literature.
I was not rejecting research or intellectual examination. I was proposing another way of establishing the authority, integrity and depth of Indigenous knowledge. This distinction remains important to understanding my work from 2013 to 2026 and I am now undertaking.
3. The Adjudication: A Personal and Intellectual Rupture
I completed the three pieces of work and submitted them for marking. However, numerous questions arose around the research and its methodology. I remember attending a meeting involving the Heads of School and my supervisors. They understood that I was strong in my positioning and that I was not easily going to abandon the intellectual foundations of my work. The strategy that followed was to have my own koroua, Distinguished Sir Professor Hirini Moko Mead, make the final adjudication of my three pieces of work. My own koroua determined that my work was, in his words, "a self-fulfilling prophecy". I still remember receiving that letter from him. I regarded this as a particularly clever ploy on behalf of the Heads of School. The final determination had been placed in the hands of my own elder, someone whose relationship with me carried considerable genealogical, cultural and intellectual significance. My academic future was effectively left to the stroke of his pen. This experience was particularly difficult because the adjudication was no longer simply an academic matter for me. It involved my relationship with my own knowledge, my whakapapa and an elder whose authority carried considerable significance in my life. The phrase "a self-fulfilling prophecy" stayed with me.
I had entered the PhD programme to research the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga in a Contemporary Context. I was attempting to articulate an Indigenous methodology that I believed was necessary for that restoration. Yet the experience of having my work adjudicated in this way left me deeply wounded. My work had been marked, and I had one year to complete the required changes.
4. The Personal Consequences
This broke me from the inside out. I had no support and nowhere to turn. The experience affected me far beyond the university environment. It reached into my relationship with my own knowledge, my whakapapa and the very foundations of what I had been attempting to establish through my research. This didn't deter me. I made me even more determined and I returned to the Waihou to live the restoration of the ancient Whare Wānanga. During this period, I was also caring for my son, whose mental health had deteriorated. Eventually, he took his own life. The loss of my son threw me into an even deeper spiral of depression and shame. I was dealing with extraordinary personal circumstances while carrying the disappointment and emotional consequences of my academic experience. These events cannot be separated from the history of my academic journey. They were happening alongside one another, and their combined impact was enormous. In 2013, I returned to the Waihou Valley in Hokianga. But something important happened that year.
5. 2016: Establishing Our Tribal Whare Wānanga
Rather than simply abandoning the kaupapa of my PhD, I began to live the very research I had been undertaking. In 2016, I established our tribal Whare Wānanga:
TE WHATUPUNGAPUNGA Ō NUKUTĀWHITI.
This Whare Wānanga continues to operate today. This is perhaps the most important development in understanding my academic journey. Although my formal university pathway had been interrupted, the kaupapa of restoring the Traditional Whare Wānanga did not end. I moved from researching the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga within a mainstream university environment to establishing and developing our own tribal Whare Wānanga. In other words, I began living the research. The knowledge, methodology and intellectual foundations that I had been attempting to articulate through my doctoral research continued to develop through my own Indigenous knowledge system and institutional framework. Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti was not simply a response to an unsuccessful academic experience. It became an enduring expression of the kaupapa that had originally taken me into doctoral research. This is an important distinction. My formal academic pathway and my Indigenous institutional development became two different but connected journeys. The university pathway was interrupted. The Whare Wānanga kaupapa continued. A few years later, following the death of my son, I contacted the university and asked whether I could return to complete my PhD.
I was not permitted to do so.
Consequently, my formal doctoral journey remained unfinished. However, the establishment of Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti in 2016 meant that the original subject of my doctoral research had continued beyond the formal university environment.
2016 to 2026 Other Significant Whare Restored
Te Whare Atua Ō IO - He Whare Atua
Te Whare Ō Kupe-Ariki - He Whare Ariki
Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti - He Whare Wānanga
Te Whare Kokorangi Ō Kupe - He Whare Tātai Arorangi
Ngā Manukura Ō Te Wakaminenga - He Matua Tū Taua
The explanation is explained throughout the book.
6. 2025: A Later Conversation with My Koroua, Distinguished Professor Sir Hirini Moko Mead
There is another important part of this story that brings my academic journey into a different perspective. In 2025, during the year before his passing, Distinguished Professor Sir Hirini Moko Mead was interviewed by Dr. Julian Wilcox on Indigenous 100, a PhD graduate of Te Whare Wānanga Ō Awanuiārangi. During that interview, Julian asked Professor Sir Hirini Moko Mead whether he believed Māori academic studies undermined the essence of the true knowledge of our ancestors. Reluctantly and eventually Professor Hirini Moko Mead answered yes. When I heard this, I became extremely excited. I immediately rang my mother, Amohaere Tangitu , and asked her for his mobile number. I wanted to speak with him personally. I rang him and told him about the interview. I explained how excited I was by his statement and how significant I considered his acknowledgement to be. I then asked him whether, as the highest-qualified Māori academic in Aotearoa, he could reinstate me so that I could complete my PhD. He laughed and responded:
"So you want me to be Merlin the Magician?"
I excitedly replied:
"Absolutely!"
He then said that he was sorry, but he could not do that. And that was where the conversation ended.
7. The Significance of That Conversation
For me, this conversation brought an extraordinary dimension to my academic journey. Years earlier, my own doctoral research had challenged the positioning of mainstream academic scholarship in relation to Indigenous knowledge. I had proposed an Applied Indigenous Knowledge methodology because I believed that ancestral knowledge, Indigenous practice and lived experience needed to be recognised as legitimate foundations of research. My work had subsequently been adjudicated by my own koroua, who described it as a "self-fulfilling prophecy". Then, years later, I heard him publicly acknowledge that Māori academic studies could undermine the essence of our ancestors' true knowledge. I was excited because I heard something in that acknowledgement that resonated deeply with the very questions I had been raising during my own doctoral research. I did not ring him to challenge him about the past. I rang because I saw an opportunity to return to the academic pathway that had been interrupted and to ask whether he could help me complete what I had started. His Merlin the Magician response was an unexpected and humorous moment between us.
Yet beneath the laughter was the reality that my request could not be fulfilled. The conversation was left there. However, it remains a significant moment in my personal and intellectual history. It brought together the original questions behind my PhD, my experience within mainstream Māori academia, my relationship with my own koroua and my continuing commitment to the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga. There is an important distinction here. His public acknowledgement of a concern about Māori academic studies was not an endorsement of my particular doctoral methodology or a reversal of the earlier adjudication. However, it brought renewed significance to the questions that had originally taken me into doctoral research. By then, I had already established Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti in 2016, and it had continued to develop beyond the university environment. The conversation did not reinstate my PhD. But the kaupapa had never stopped.
8. 2015–2026: Eleven Years Away, Twelve Calendar Years of Development
I effectively left the formal academic pathway in 2015 and did not return to this particular body of writing until 2026. That represents eleven elapsed years, or twelve calendar years when counting inclusively. However, those years were not years in which the underlying kaupapa disappeared. Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti continued. My research continued. My understanding of Indigenous knowledge, traditional institutions, whakapapa and the restoration of the Whare Wānanga continued to develop. The difference was that I was no longer attempting to have the entire kaupapa validated through a mainstream academic institution. I was developing and living the knowledge through our own tribal Whare Wānanga. This distinction is important because it prevents my academic history from being reduced to an unfinished qualification. My formal doctorate remained incomplete, but my intellectual and institutional work continued. The years between 2015 and 2026 were part of that continuing development.
9. The Three Stages of My Intellectual Journey
Looking back, I can now distinguish three significant stages in my intellectual development.
FIRST STAGE: 2008–2012 — FORMAL ACADEMIC FORMATION
This was the period in which I returned to formal education, completed my Bachelor's and Master's degrees in Mātauranga Māori, and entered doctoral research. It was during this period that I developed and proposed my Applied Indigenous Knowledge methodology. My intellectual focus was the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga in a Contemporary Context.
SECOND STAGE: 2016–2026 — INDIGENOUS INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT
This was the period in which I established Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti and continued developing the kaupapa outside the mainstream university environment. Rather than abandoning my original research subject, I established my own Whare Wānanga with the support of over 45 kaumātua from Aotearoa and Te Moana Nui ā Hīva. The research became an ongoing institutional and Indigenous knowledge kaupapa.
THIRD STAGE: 2026 ONWARDS — ARTICULATION AND PUBLICATION
This is the period in which I have returned to writing with another purpose. I am now articulating a much larger body of intellectual, Indigenous and institutional work. The book I am writing is not simply an attempt to finish an unfinished academic assignment. It is part of the continuation of a kaupapa that has developed over many years. These three stages are connected, but they are not interchangeable. Each represents a different stage of my journey.
10. My Return to Writing in 2026
Here I am in 2026, returning to writing with another purpose. I now look back at that period and recognise that my mainstream academic experience was only one part of a much larger journey. I entered university in 2008 carrying shame and uncertainty following my return from Australia. Within three years, I had completed two qualifications in Mātauranga Māori. By the end of 2012, I had entered doctoral research proposing an Applied Indigenous Knowledge methodology. My academic journey was interrupted by a deeply personal and painful experience, compounded by the deterioration of my son's mental health and his eventual death. But the kaupapa did not stop. In 2016, I established Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti, Our tribal Whare Wānanga, which continues today. That is perhaps the most important part of this history. I had originally entered the PhD programme to research the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga in a Contemporary Context. After leaving the formal academic environment, I established and continued developing our tribal Whare Wānanga. The book we are now writing in 2026 must therefore be understood against that entire background. It is not simply a return to an unfinished PhD. It is the continuation of a kaupapa that has been developing for many years, through formal academic study, Indigenous practice, personal adversity and the establishment of my own Whare Wānanga.
11. The Distinction Between an Unfinished Doctorate and an Uninterrupted Kaupapa
I think it is important to make this distinction clear.
I did not complete my PhD within the mainstream university system. That remains a fact of my academic history. However, my doctoral subject was the restoration of the Traditional Whare Wānanga in a Contemporary Context. In 2016, I established Te Whatupungapunga Ō Nukutāwhiti. It continues today. Consequently, my intellectual journey cannot be understood solely through the qualification I did not complete. It must also be understood through the Indigenous institution I established and the kaupapa that has continued beyond the university environment. I entered mainstream academia seeking to develop an understanding of the Traditional Whare Wānanga.
I encountered the intellectual and methodological boundaries of that academic environment. I experienced a deeply painful adjudication involving my own koroua. I experienced the loss of my son and the interruption of my formal academic pathway. Yet I returned to Hokianga and established our tribal Whare Wānanga. That is an important part of my history. The university chapter of my research was interrupted. The kaupapa of restoring the Traditional Whare Wānanga continued. That is the distinction between an interrupted academic qualification and an uninterrupted intellectual and Indigenous institutional kaupapa. And that is the journey I bring into the writing of this book in 2026.